Return to Videos

Video Transcript

What is Goodwill in the Context of a Business Purchase?

Goodwill in a business refers to an intangible asset that arises when a company is purchased for more than the fair value of its identifiable net assets (assets minus liabilities). It represents the value of the business’s brand reputation, customer relationships, employee morale, proprietary technology, or other non-physical assets that give it a competitive edge.

Key Aspects of Goodwill

• Intangible Asset: Goodwill is not a physical item like inventory or buildings. It captures value beyond tangible and separately identifiable intangible assets (like patents or trademarks).
• Only Recorded in Acquisitions: Goodwill only appears on the balance sheet when a company is acquired. Organically grown businesses do not record goodwill as an asset.
• Calculation Example: If Company A buys Company B for $10 million, but the fair market value of B’s net identifiable assets is $7 million, the $3 million difference is recorded as goodwill.

Types of Goodwill

• Enterprise Goodwill: Tied to the business itself (e.g., location, reputation, trained workforce). Usually transferable or salable.
• Personal Goodwill: Tied to individuals (e.g., a founder’s reputation or relationships). Often not transferable — especially relevant in valuation disputes or divorces.

Impairment

Under U.S. GAAP and IFRS, goodwill is not amortized but must be tested annually for impairment. If the business value drops below book value (including goodwill), it must be written down, affecting earnings.

Why It Matters

• In M&A: Often a significant portion of the purchase price.
• In Valuation: Important in shareholder disputes, divorces, and financial reporting.
• In Accounting: Impacts the balance sheet and may have legal or tax implications.

Real-World Example

A dental practice owned by Dr. Smith:
If patients visit because of Dr. Smith’s personal reputation — that’s personal goodwill.
If the practice retains patients through systems, staff, and branding regardless of the dentist — that’s enterprise goodwill.

Buyers may discount personal goodwill because it’s not transferable.
Courts in many states (unlike NJ) often exclude personal goodwill from marital estate division, but count enterprise goodwill.

Personal Goodwill in Litigation Contexts

Divorce Example

In Levine v. Levine (New Jersey App. Div.), the court held that personal goodwill attributable to an individual attorney in a law firm was not distributable in equitable distribution.

Shareholder Dispute Example

In forced buyouts, buyers may argue much of the goodwill is personal (lowering valuation), while sellers may argue it’s enterprise (inflating value).

Key Tests to Distinguish Goodwill Types

• Is the goodwill tied to the person or the company?
• Would clients stay if the individual left?
• Is there a non-compete or employment contract that could make personal goodwill transferable?

Goodwill Classification Checklist

Question	Indicator of Personal Goodwill	Indicator of Enterprise Goodwill
Do clients/patients/customers come primarily because of one person?	Yes	No
Would the business lose substantial value if that person left?	Yes	No
Is there a formal non-compete or employment agreement?	No (suggests personal)	Yes (suggests transferability = enterprise)
Are customer relationships documented and handled by multiple staff?	No	Yes
Is the business name the individual’s name (e.g., “Dr. Smith, DDS”)?	Yes	No
Are business processes, systems, or brand strong enough to retain customers regardless of personnel?	No	Yes
Could the business be sold to a third party and continue to operate successfully?	Unlikely	Likely
Does the business have recurring revenue not dependent on any one person?	No	Yes
Is the business part of a franchise, chain, or branded operation?	Rarely	Often

Key New Jersey Case Law

New Jersey case law generally does not distinguish between personal and enterprise goodwill, finding it too difficult to prove and separate the two.